Robert michels iron law of oligarchy pdf

It states that all forms of organization, regardless of how democratic or autocratic they may be at the start, will eventually and inevitably. While democracy means rule of the people, oligarchy is the rule of the few, the rule of a powerful elite. A look at michels s iron law of oligarchy michels s analysis appeared in 1911 in a book titled political parties. Michels sought to explain why democraticallyrun political parties in. It asserts that rule by an elite, or oligarchy, is inevitable as an iron law within any democratic organization as part of the tactical and technical necessities of organization. We were taught about something called the iron law of oligarchy.

In this context, the classic analysis offered by robert michels 1962 of typical evolutionary processes in the governance of political organizations, and the impact of such processes on organizations goals, is very relevant to scholars of social movements. In this article we will discuss about the iron law of oligarchy by robert michels. In 1911 robert michels argued that 2 3 at the time michels formulated his law, he was an anarchosyndicalist. The iron law of oligarchy contends that organizational democracy is an oxymoron. Using indepth interviews with union organizers and staff, as well as secondary data on particular.

Fifa and the iron law of oligarchy unanticipated knowledge. In 1911, robert michels embarked on one of the earliest investigations into organisational culture. Get pdf 320 kb abstract excerpt resource mobilization, a dominant theoretical approach to the study of social movements for many decades, points to social movement organizations smos as a focal point for efforts to understand the variations in both the impact and fate of. Iron law of oligarchy by robert michels sociology discussion. Robert michels oligarchy taken from oscar grusky and george a. It is argued that athens success es related to its practice of universal male citizen participation in the administration of the city.

Robert michels germanitalian sociologist britannica. Iron law of oligarchy last updated january 15, 2020. Michels argued that organisations are inherently oligarchic. Its first proponent, robert michels, contended in 1911 that as administration and technology become more complex, experts with dominant personalities are needed to steer the masses. According to michels, if a democratic organization doesnt portray true democracy, then a nondemocratic organization can never be truly democratic. The law that it is an essential characteristic of all human aggregates to constitute cliques and subclasses is, like every other sociological law, beyond good and evil. In the iron law of oligarchy, robert michels stated that bureaucracy always means a. Thus mormonism became in the words of thomas odea a democracy of participation and an oligarchy of decisionmaking and command quoted from quinn, p. Democracy leads to oligarchy, and necessarily contains an oligarchical. In this book, he described a principle that he called the iron law of oligarchy. Although elite control makes internal democracy unsustainable, it is also said to shape the longterm development of all organizationsincluding the rhetorically most radicalin a conservative direction. In this context, the classic analysis offered by robert michels 1911 1962 of typical evolutionary processes in the governance of political organizations, and the impact of such processes on organizations goals, is very relevant to scholars of social movements. Pdf the iron law of oligarchy refers to a provocative and very influential theory posited by german social theorist, robert michels. These organisations were ostensibly anticapitalist and.

Robert michels wrote a book in 1911 called political parties. This article shows how athens in the late fifth and early fourth centuries mitigated robert michels famous iron law of oligarchy. Pdf more than 100 years ago, robert michels laid out his theory of the iron law of oligarchy. Jul 15, 2009 the iron law of oligarchy is a political theory, first developed by the german syndicalist sociologist robert michels in his 1911 book, political parties. Iron law of oligarchy wikimili, the best wikipedia reader. In the englishspeaking world, he is most famous for his book political parties 1911, in which he formulated the problem of the oligarchic tendencies of organizations. A theory of trade unions and socialist political parties formulated by the sociologist, robert michels, in the early years of the twentieth century. Robert michels and the iron law of oligarchy by pamela s. The theory has had most influence on the analysis of trade unions and is associated with the view. Robert michels argument about the iron law of oligarchy is as simple as it is powerful. In his seminal analysis of the german social democratic party in.

The italian sociologist robert michels 18761936 published in 1911 a book entitled political parties. It states that all forms of organization, regardless of how democratic or autocratic they may be at the start, will eventually and inevitably develop into oligarchies. Why michels iron law of oligarchy is not an iron law and how. Thus the current revitalization of the movement raises the question of how some organizations have been able to break out of this bureaucratic conservatism. The iron law of oligarchy by radbod robert michels was born in cologne, germany in 1876. Robert michels, political parties, 42 may be certain that there is on such occasions a drama of jealousy being played beneath the surface. Coined by the german sociologist robert michels in his 1911 monograph political parties, the iron law of oligarchy refers to the inbuilt tendency of all complex social organizations to turn bureaucratic and highly undemocratic. In abstracto, it makes all citizens equal before the law. Probably the most famous dictum about parties internal structures is robert michels iron law of oligarchy.

It derives its power from the very organization of society itself. This article specifies the key assumptions of michels s theory and tests them by the use of two data sets that focus on collective protest and the evolution of organizational features of german new social movement groups. Robert michels s iron law of oligarchy has rarely been submitted to rigorous empirical investigation. More than 100 years ago, robert michels laid out his theory of the iron law of oligarchy. Start studying sociology 101 quiz questions chapter 5. Robert michels spelled out the iron law of oligarchy in the first decade of the 20th century in political parties, a brilliant comparative study of european socialist. Iron law of oligarchy pdf the iron law of oligarchy is a political theory, first developed by the german sociologist robert political parties by robert michels in pdf. One of the first detailed examinations of party organisations, michels political parties 1949i is probably best known for what michels called the iron law of oligarchy michels, 1949. Robert michels was a german sociologist who spent the last 10 years of his life in italy. Robert michels and the iron law of oligarchy pamela s. This article specifies the key assumptions of michels s theory and tests them by the use of two data sets that focus on collective protest and the evolution of organizational features of. It was a concept coined by robert michels, a friend of sociology guru, max weber, way back in 1911.

According to the theory, no matter how democratic at the start, all forms of largescale organizationsdemocratic or nondemocraticeventually. This is a study of european socialist parties and trade unions with particular reference to the german socialist party. Abstract the iron law of oligarchy refers to a provocative and very in. Over the past two decades, however, the societal context within which parties are embedded has begun to change which may alter the psychological premise upon which michels law is based. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.

Iron law of oligarchy is a theory of organization first developed by german sociologist robert michels in his 1911 study of the german social democratic party. Michels s iron law of oligarchy robert michels 1876 1936, was a young historian who had been unable to get a job in the german university system, despite the recommendation of max weber, because he was a member of the social democrats. He examined democratic socialist political parties, assuming that here democratic practices would be at their zenith. It gives to each one of them the possibility of ascending to the top of the social scale, and thus facilitates the way for the rights of the community, annulling before the law. This work, first published in german in 1911 introduced the concept of iron law of oligarchy. He who says organization, he asserted, says oligarchy. The iron law of oligarchy is a political theory, first developed by the german syndicalist sociologist robert michels in his 1911 book, political parties. Trade union, strike action, bureaucracy, democracy, political.

A lingering theory suggests there is an iron law of oligarchy afflicting social democratic parties in general, and trade unions in particular. Michelss iron law of oligarchy robert michels 1876 1936, was a young historian who had been unable to get a job in the german university system, despite the recommendation of max weber, because he was a member of the social democrats. This work, political parties, is a real classic in the study of politics. Which of these concepts was used by robert michels to refer to the rule of the many by the few. Robert michels and the iron law of oligarchy 2010 available at.

Robert michels, political parties, 8 the right of one over others. Although iron law of oligarchy, sociological thesis according to which all organizations, including those committed to democratic ideals and practices, will inevitably succumb to rule by an elite few an oligarchy. Pdf why michels iron law of oligarchy is not an iron law and. Robert michels, a historian who lived between 1876 and 1936, wrote a book in 1911 called political parties. The iron law of oligarchy is a political theory, first developed by the german sociologist robert michels in his 1911 book, political parties. Oligarchy, iron law of bibliography 1 coined by the german sociologist robert michels 2 in his 1911 monograph political parties, the iron law of oligarchy refers to the inbuilt tendency of all complex social organizations to turn bureaucratic and highly undemocratic. Robert michels and the iron law of oligarchy electronic version. According to the theory, no matter how democratic at the start, all forms of largescale organizationsdemocratic or nondemocraticeventually and inevitably lead to oligarchic. May 21, 2012 this german sociologist robert michel argued that no matter how democratic and altruistic any movement is at its inception, whoever says organization, says oligarchy. The commentary on this hypothesis has usually been motivated by a desire to attack or to support it. In this book, he described a concept he named the iron law of oligarchy.

Pdf why michels iron law of oligarchy is not an iron law. The iron law of oligarchy in the athenian polis and today. Both communists and fascists typically support the creation of mass movements as a means to overthrow a government and create their own government, the mass. He is best known for his book political parties, published in 1911, which contains a description of the iron law of. Robert michels spelled out the iron law of oligarchy in. The iron law of oligarchy refers to a provocative and very influential theory posited by german social theorist, robert michels. Robert michels 1876 1936, was a young historian who had been unable to get a job in the german university. The iron law of oligarchy in the athenian polis and. Pdf why michels iron law of oligarchy is not an iron. Iron law of oligarchy article about iron law of oligarchy. Iron law of oligarchy wikipedia republished wiki 2. In his seminal analysis of the german social democratic party in 1911, michels argued that all organizations no matter how democratic their.

Below, the key processes involved in what michels referred to as the iron law of oligarchy are sketched, followed by a brief discussion of some of the implications of this analysis for social movement researchers. One of the most interesting generalizations in the field of social science is robert michels iron law of oligarchy. Iron law of oligarchy project gutenberg selfpublishing. Michels was a pioneering sociologist, a student of max weber. The main, and crucial, point michels made is that oligarchy will always emerge.

This work analyzes the power structures of organizations such as political parties and trade unions. Iron law of oligarchy sociological thesis britannica. Why michels iron law of oligarchy is not an iron law and. Michels iron law of oligarchy article about michels iron. Michels stressed several factors that underlie the iron law of oligarchy. Sociology 101 quiz questions chapter 5 flashcards quizlet. According to michels, even the leftwing parties of western europe in the pre world war i era, which were programmatically. There is a demagogic struggle, fierce, masked, and obstinate, between one leader and another, and the mass has to intervene in. Political movements that typically advocate the creation of a mass movement include the ideologies of communism and fascism. It is considered one of the classics of social sciences, in particular sociology and political science. Publication date 1915 topics political parties, democracy publisher new york, hearsts international library co.

742 714 202 1562 1020 215 491 1539 709 526 52 1049 352 436 832 27 537 196 700 1311 1128 472 82 204 887 947 282 940 559 1139 79 553 413 631 1034 1199 1040 271 842 487 1011 1485 935